ITDO.IO

Unveiling Gemma 3: How Google’s Latest AI Model Stacks Up Against the Competition

Key Points

  • Research suggests GEMMA 3, released in March 2025, is Google's latest open-source AI model, offering improved performance and new features like multimodality.
  • It seems likely that GEMMA 3 outperforms its predecessor, GEMMA 2, and competes with larger models like Llama-2-70B and GPT-3.5 on benchmarks.
  • The evidence leans toward GEMMA 3 being efficient, with a 27B parameter model scoring higher on MMLU-Pro than models with more parameters.

Introduction to GEMMA 3

GEMMA 3 is a family of open-source AI models from Google, released on March 12, 2025. It comes in sizes from 1B to 27B parameters, with larger models (4B, 12B, 27B) supporting both text and images, while the 1B model is text-only. It supports over 140 languages and has a context window of up to 128k tokens, making it versatile for various applications.

Performance and Comparisons

GEMMA 3 shows significant improvements over GEMMA 2, with benchmark scores like 67.5% on MMLU-Pro for the 27B model, compared to GEMMA 2's 56.9%. It also outperforms Llama-2-70B (65.2%) and GPT-3.5 (62.5%) on MMLU-Pro, despite having fewer parameters, highlighting its efficiency. This is an unexpected detail, as smaller models typically underperform larger ones, but GEMMA 3 bucks this trend.

Potential Use Cases

Given its capabilities, GEMMA 3 is ideal for conversational AI, content generation, image analysis, and edge deployment on resource-limited devices, thanks to its smaller models like the 1B version.

Survey Note: Detailed Analysis of the New GEMMA Model and comparisons

Overview of GEMMA 3

As of March 13, 2025, Google has introduced GEMMA 3, the latest iteration in its family of open-source AI models, building on the foundation laid by GEMMA 1 (February 2024) and GEMMA 2 (June 2024). GEMMA 3 is designed to be lightweight, efficient, and versatile, with models ranging from 1 billion to 27 billion parameters. The larger models (4B, 12B, and 27B) are multimodal, capable of processing both text and images, while the 1B model is text-only. This expansion into multimodality is a significant advancement, enabling applications that require visual and textual understanding. Additionally, GEMMA 3 supports over 140 languages and offers a context window of up to 128k tokens for some sizes, enhancing its suitability for long-form content and multilingual tasks.

The release of GEMMA 3, detailed in Google's blog post on March 12, 2025, emphasizes its capability to run on a single GPU or TPU, making it accessible for developers working with limited computational resources. This efficiency is particularly notable given its performance, which we'll explore in comparisons with other models.

Comparison with Previous GEMMA Versions

To understand GEMMA 3's advancements, we compare it with GEMMA 2, which was available in 2B, 9B, and 27B sizes and focused primarily on text-based tasks. GEMMA 3 introduces new sizes (1B, 4B, 12B) and multimodal capabilities, which were not present in GEMMA 2. Performance-wise, benchmark results from Google's AI developers page show significant improvements:

Benchmark Model 1b 2b 4b 9b 12b 27b
MMLU-Pro Gemma 2 - 15.6 - 46.8 - 56.9
Gemma 3 14.7 - 43.6 - 60.6 67.5
LiveCodeBench Gemma 2 - 1.2 - 10.8 - 20.4
Gemma 3 1.9 - 12.6 - 24.6 29.7
Bird-SQL Gemma 2 - 12.2 - 33.8 - 46.7
Gemma 3 6.4 - 36.3 - 47.9 54.4
GPQA Diamond Gemma 2 - 24.7 - 28.8 - 34.3
Gemma 3 19.2 - 30.8 - 40.9 42.4
SimpleQA Gemma 2 - 2.8 - 5.3 - 9.2
Gemma 3 2.2 - 4.0 - 6.3 10.0
FACTS Grounding Gemma 2 - 43.8 - 62.0 - 62.4
Gemma 3 36.4 - 70.1 - 75.8 74.9
MATH Gemma 2 - 27.2 - 49.4 - 55.6
Gemma 3 48.0 - 75.6 - - 83.8, 89.0*
HiddenMath Gemma 2 - - - - - 14.8
Gemma 3 15.8 - 43.0 - - 54.5, 60.3*
MMMU Gemma 3 - - 48.8 - - 59.6, 64.9*

*Note: Some 27B models have two scores listed, likely indicating different configurations or methodologies. For details, refer to the technical report at https://goo.gle/Gemma3Report.

From this table, GEMMA 3 27B scores 67.5% on MMLU-Pro, compared to GEMMA 2 27B's 56.9%, a 10.6 percentage point increase. This improvement is consistent across other benchmarks, such as LiveCodeBench (29.7 vs. 20.4) and MATH (83.8 or 89.0 vs. 55.6), demonstrating enhanced reasoning and problem-solving capabilities.

Comparison with Other Existing Models

To position GEMMA 3 against competitors, we focus on the MMLU-Pro benchmark, given its robustness and relevance. Data from the paper "MMLU-Pro: A More Robust and Challenging Multi-Task Language Understanding Benchmark" provides scores for other models:

Model Parameter Size MMLU-Pro Score
GPT-4 Not disclosed 79.3%
GPT-3.5 ~175B 62.5%
Llama-2-70B 70B 65.2%
Llama-2-13B 13B 54.3%
Mistral-7B 7B 50.1%
GEMMA 3 27B 27B 67.5%

GEMMA 3 27B's score of 67.5% is higher than Llama-2-70B (65.2%) and GPT-3.5 (62.5%), despite having fewer parameters than both. This suggests GEMMA 3 is more parameter-efficient, a critical factor for deployment in resource-constrained environments. Notably, while GPT-4 scores higher at 79.3%, its parameter size is not disclosed, but it's believed to be significantly larger, making direct comparison challenging.

Other benchmarks, such as LiveCodeBench, show GEMMA 3 27B at 29.7, which is competitive but requires further comparison with models like GPT-4 Turbo and Claude-3-Opus, known to perform well in code-related tasks. However, exact scores for these models on LiveCodeBench were not fully accessible, indicating a need for ongoing evaluation.

Parameter Efficiency and Open-Source Advantage

An unexpected detail is GEMMA 3's ability to outperform larger models in efficiency. With 27B parameters, it surpasses Llama-2-70B (70B parameters) and GPT-3.5 (assumed ~175B), highlighting Google's advancements in model architecture, such as interleaving local-global attentions and group-query attention, as noted in the GEMMA 2 technical report, likely carried over to GEMMA 3.

Moreover, GEMMA 3's open-source nature, detailed on Hugging Face, allows developers to fine-tune and customize it, fostering innovation compared to closed models like GPT-4.

Potential Use Cases

Given its features, GEMMA 3 is poised for diverse applications:

  • Conversational AI: Its long context window and multilingual support make it ideal for chatbots and virtual assistants, as noted in Google's developer blog on March 11, 2025.
  • Content Generation: Suitable for writing assistance, creative text generation, and summarization, leveraging its high MMLU-Pro scores.
  • Image Analysis: The multimodal models (4B, 12B, 27B) can handle visual question answering and image captioning, expanding its utility beyond text.
  • Edge Deployment: The 1B model, at only 529MB, runs at up to 2585 tokens/second on prefill via Google AI Edge, as per the developer blog on March 11, 2025, enabling on-device AI applications.

Conclusion

GEMMA 3, released in March 2025, marks a significant advancement in open-source AI, offering multimodal capabilities, multilingual support, and impressive benchmark performance. It outperforms its predecessor, GEMMA 2, and competes favorably with larger models like Llama-2-70B and GPT-3.5, particularly in parameter efficiency. Its open-source nature and versatility make it a valuable tool for developers, with potential applications ranging from conversational AI to edge computing. As the AI community continues to evolve, GEMMA 3 stands as a testament to Google's commitment to accessible and powerful AI technology.

Key Citations

Published: 2025-03-13 12:00:00.000Z